Logan County is a small community. That means when someone is killed by another person’s negligence or recklessness, the whole county feels it in a way that doesn’t happen in larger places.
In January 2024, Chloe Hodge, a 17-year-old from Indian Lake High School who was studying nursing at Ohio Hi-Point and worked at Hurley Farms, was killed in a head-on crash on a Logan County road when a driver crossed the center line while allegedly impaired. Dozens of her classmates, friends, and family members filled the Logan County Court of Common Pleas for the sentencing of the woman responsible. She received 11 to 16.5 years in prison.
In June 2024, Brittnie Whetsel, 32, of Bellefontaine, was a passenger in a vehicle on County Road 29 when the driver failed to negotiate a curve and overturned the vehicle. She was transported to Mary Rutan Hospital with serious injuries and died the following day. More than a year later, a Logan County Grand Jury indicted the driver on two counts of aggravated vehicular homicide. He was arrested, sentenced, and briefly incarcerated.
These are real cases from our community. And in both of them, the criminal justice system ran its course, charges were filed, courts were involved, and sentences were handed down. What the criminal process doesn’t do, however, is put a dollar in the hands of the surviving family. It doesn’t pay for a funeral. It doesn’t replace the income a family depended on. It doesn’t compensate for the loss of a person who was central to someone else’s life.
That’s what Ohio’s wrongful death law exists to do. And it runs completely separately from any criminal case. If you ever find yourself in this type of situation, you can contact us right away. We can help you.
The Criminal Case and the Civil Case Are Not the Same Thing
This is one of the most important things families in Logan County need to understand after losing someone to another person’s negligence.
When Briana Mohler was charged with aggravated vehicular homicide for killing Chloe Hodge, that case was brought by the State of Ohio. The Hodge family had no control over it. The outcome — a prison sentence — doesn’t financially compensate Chloe’s family for anything.
A wrongful death claim under Ohio Revised Code Chapter 2125 is a civil action, brought separately by the personal representative of the deceased’s estate, for the financial benefit of the surviving family. It exists regardless of whether the responsible party was ever charged with a crime. It exists regardless of whether they were convicted. A defendant can be acquitted in criminal court and still be found liable in a civil wrongful death case; the standards of proof are completely different.
You don’t need to wait for the criminal case to conclude. You don’t need a conviction to pursue a wrongful death claim. And critically, the two-year clock under ORC § 2125.02(F) starts running from the date of your loved one’s death, not from the date of any criminal sentencing or resolution.
For a free legal consultation, call 937-530-4286
What Logan County Families Actually Lose
The Logan County Sheriff’s Office reported 4 fatal crashes in its jurisdiction in 2024, alongside 198 injury crashes. Those 4 families experienced a version of what the law recognizes as wrongful death damages, losses that Ohio’s wrongful death statute enumerates specifically and allows families to pursue:
- Loss of income and financial support. When someone who contributed to a household’s finances is killed, that financial gap is real and ongoing. Ohio law allows families to pursue the full present value of what the deceased would have earned over their remaining working years — calculated using their age, career trajectory, and earning history.
- Loss of services. This category is underappreciated but significant, particularly in Logan County’s rural households where a family member might have handled everything from equipment maintenance to childcare to managing the farm. These contributions have real economic value, and Ohio law recognizes them.
- Loss of society. Ohio Revised Code § 2125.02(D) defines this broadly and intentionally so. It includes loss of companionship, consortium, care, guidance, counsel, instruction, training, and education. For a family who lost a parent, a spouse, or a child, the law doesn’t reduce that person to a wage figure. It acknowledges the full dimension of what they meant to the people around them.
- Mental anguish. Grief is compensable under Ohio law. The surviving spouse, dependent children, parents, and next of kin are all recognized as having suffered a real, documentable injury when someone they love is taken from them.
- Funeral and burial expenses. These immediate costs, often thousands of dollars that fall on a family already in shock, are directly recoverable in a wrongful death claim.
Bellefontaine Personal Injury Lawyer Near Me 937-530-4286
Who Brings the Wrongful Case and Who Benefits
Ohio’s wrongful death statute assigns the legal task of bringing the claim to the personal representative of the estate — typically someone named in the deceased’s will, or appointed by the Logan County Probate Court if there is no will. This is an important step that our office helps families navigate, because a wrongful death claim cannot move forward without this appointment.
The personal representative files the claim, but the compensation flows directly to the beneficiaries. Under ORC § 2125.02(A), the primary beneficiaries are the surviving spouse, the children of the deceased, and the parents of the deceased. Courts apportion the recovery among beneficiaries based on the losses each has suffered.
If there are multiple family members with a potential interest in the claim, a spouse and adult children from a prior relationship, for instance, or parents and siblings, the process of identifying beneficiaries and apportioning recovery requires careful legal guidance. We’ve handled these situations before, and we know how to manage them with fairness and transparency for everyone involved.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
The Survival Claim: What Happened Between the Injury and the Death
In cases where your loved one survived for a period (hours, days, or longer) before dying from their injuries, Ohio law provides a second, separate avenue for recovery: a survival claim under ORC § 2305.21.
The survival claim belongs to the estate, not the beneficiaries directly, and it compensates for what the deceased themselves experienced after the negligent act: conscious pain and suffering, medical expenses incurred before death, and other losses the person endured before they died. In cases like Brittnie Whetsel’s, where she was hospitalized with serious injuries and died the following day, a survival claim would cover everything she experienced in those final hours.
These two claims, wrongful death and survival, are legally distinct and distributed differently, but both can be pursued simultaneously. Understanding how they interact, and how to maximize recovery under each, is part of what we bring to these cases.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Timing Matters inWrongful Death Cases
The two-year statute of limitations is real, and it doesn’t pause while a criminal case moves through the courts. But there’s a more immediate reason that reaching out to an attorney early matters: evidence.
In the Whetsel case, it took more than a year from the crash to the indictment and investigators had to work carefully to establish who was actually driving, because the driver initially denied it. Civil cases face similar evidentiary challenges. Crash reconstruction. Toxicology. Vehicle data. Witness memory. Phone records. All of it degrades with time, and some of it disappears entirely if it isn’t specifically preserved.
Our Bellefontaine injury lawyers can be involved from the earliest stages, even while a criminal investigation is ongoing. We coordinate carefully to ensure that civil evidence preservation doesn’t interfere with the criminal process, but we don’t wait passively while the clock runs.
Contact Kruger & Hodges in Bellefontaine
Wrongful death cases are the most serious work we do. We approach them accordingly, with patience, with care, and with the full commitment of an attorney who answers your calls directly.
Our office at 139 W. Columbus Ave., Suite 304 in Bellefontaine is right here in Logan County. There is no fee unless we recover for you. Don’t hesitate to contact us for a free consultation.
Call or text 937-530-4286 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
